Question

Jude, seated in a chair and lost in thought, gave me a sudde

Answer 1

A

as if to say “好像要说”，与gave me a sudden look语境相符。as if to have said “好像已经说了”，as if said “好像已经被说了”，要表达“好像在说”应用as if saying 而不是as if to be saying。